A recession is expected in an economy within the next year. Portfolio Manager A has shifted more of their stocks from the financial industry to the health care industry. Portfolio Manager B has shifted more of their stocks from the technology industry to the utility industry. Which of the following statements is most accurate regarding the performance of each manager? A) | Portfolio Manager A is expected to outperform the broad market and Portfolio Manager B is expected to outperform the broad market. |
| B) | Portfolio Manager A is expected to underperform the broad market and Portfolio Manager B is expected to underperform the broad market. |
| C) | Portfolio Manager A is expected to outperform the broad market while Portfolio Manager B is expected to underperform the broad market. |
| D) | Portfolio Manager A is expected to underperform the broad market while Portfolio Manager B is expected to outperform the broad market. |
|
Answer and Explanation
Both managers are exhibiting style drift. Manager As drift is actually beneficial to performance while Bs is not. Value managers tend to have greater representation in the utility and financial industries whereas growth managers tend to have higher weights in the technology and health care industries. Growth stocks are more likely to outperform during a recession as there are few other firms with growth prospects and a premium would be placed on growth stocks valuation. |