Session 7: Financial Reporting and Analysis: An Introduction Reading 30: Financial Reporting Mechanics
LOS g: Explain the use of the results of the accounting process in security analysis.
Jack Rivers is an investment analyst for the equity fund of a family office. The head of the family, Charlotte Blackmon, is concerned that management may be manipulating the earnings of some of the companies that the fund invests in. Rivers explains to Blackmon, “Even though we don’t have access to the detailed transactions that underlie the financial statements, we can be sure that management is not manipulating earnings because I read the footnotes to the financial statements of every company we invest in. The footnotes would disclose any deviation from appropriate accounting parameters.” Rivers is:
|
B) |
incorrect because deviation from appropriate accounting parameters is addressed in the auditor’s report, so a qualified opinion in the auditor’s report ensures that management is not manipulating earnings. | |
C) |
incorrect because even within appropriate accounting parameters, management can manipulate earnings through the assumptions that rely on their discretion. | |
Because adjustments and assumptions within the financial statements are to some extent at the discretion of management, the possibility exists that management can try to manipulate or misrepresent the company’s financial performance. A clean auditor’s report does not ensure that management is unable to manipulate earnings, and a qualified opinion expresses reservations about the appropriateness of accounting policies. An analyst doesn’t have access to the detailed information that flows through a company’s accounting system, but only sees its end product, the financial statements. |