Board logo

标题: 关于using data from websites without citing the source 算不算misrepresantation的疑问(Lev [打印本页]

作者: morrowtan    时间: 2014-5-29 21:38     标题: 关于using data from websites without citing the source 算不算misrepresantation的疑问(Lev

考试临近,头脑越来越不清楚了,最近碰到了两道很相似但答案完全相反的的题目,关于 using data from websites without citing the source 算不算misrepresantation的,请各位大神帮忙解难啊~~~~
1. Jean-Luc Schlumberger, CFA, is an independent research analyst providing equity research on companies listed on exchanges in emerging markets. He often incorporates statistical data he obtained from the web sites of the World Bank and the Central Banks of the various countries into the body of his research reports. While not indicated within the reports, whenever his clients ask where he gets his information he informs them the information the information is in the public domain, so he doesn't keep his own records. When the clients ask for the specific web site addresses he provides the information. Which Standard has Schlumberger most likely violated?

A. misconduct
B. Record Retention
C. misrepresentation

Answer: C

Schlumberger has plagiarized the information he obtained from the websites of the World Bank and the various Central Banks by not quoting the sources within the research reports. This is a violation of Standard I - Professionalism (C) Misrepresentation.

2. Bill Cooper finds a table of historical bond yields on the website of the U.S. Treasury that supports the work he has done in this analysis and indudes the table as part of his report without citing the source.Has cooper violated the code and standard?
A Yes,because he did not cite the source of the table
B Yes,because he did not verify the accuray of the information
C No,because the table is from a recongnized source of finacial or statistical data

Answer: C
According to Standard I(C) Misrepresentation,members and candidates must cite the source of the information they use in their analysis,unless the information is factual data(as opposed to analysis or opinion) from a recongnized finacial or statistical reporting service. The U.S.Treasury is one example of a recongnized source of factual data.

请问两题的情景与条件有哪些不同,导致了两个不同的结果?
作者: morrowtan    时间: 2014-5-31 07:58

默默顶一下等大神来临。。。
作者: adjani.zhang    时间: 2014-5-31 15:51

回复 2# morrowtan


Information from recognized financial and statistical reporting services need not be cited.
可能有name list,列表以外的都不算"recognized" ?




欢迎光临 CFA论坛 (http://forum.theanalystspace.com/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2