返回列表 发帖

大家覺得CFA課程與現實相符嗎?

I just finished my CFA level 3 exam and I am in engineering. I am thinking how much of the material are actually being used in reality and ibanking. Any thoughts?

I don't know how to apply my knowledge to help me to do personal investing, e.g. I probably wont calculate beta before buying a stock and as a average investor, you wont have access to most historical data anyway. And seems like the whole class is just suggesting you to buy index and you can't beat the market most of the time with active management. Apart from making your resume nicer, how do you think this exam can help you?

Also, it seems like estimating all those parameters with high and low values will give you a ridiculous range of final values which help you nothing. E.g. The high estimate of this stock is 1000 dollars and low is 50 dollars. Do you buy now???

And how do you actually find out r and g in reality with reasonable accuracy??

I am not any way better at picking stock than before taking the exam i really want to learn something practical.

[此贴子已经被作者于2010-6-10 4:40:02编辑过]

QUOTE:
以下是引用tommyyxh在2010-6-10 11:13:00的发言:

不好意思,那是中国吧,这个道德再中国没法混,因为再中国,投资行业没有道德可言!!!

不过在国外,监管还是很严的,尊崇CFA的道德标准一个是可以帮你避免违法,一个是让客户对你有信心。。。

 

不过说真的,CFA真的不该去中国,中国特色,CFA是水土不服的!!!!

中国特色可没整出次贷危机吧,您的这个“国外”是不是不包括美国啊

TOP

 Most of the time it is not about how much it can be utilized in real life but the fundamental concept and the methodology learned from the <a href="http://www.vast-talent.com/certification/finance/cfa">CFA courses</a> that counts.

TOP

QUOTE:
以下是引用z3237515在2010-5-13 10:37:00的发言:
多谢楼主分享经验。我也觉得CFAi会在3级上加大难度,08年12月过的1级,去年6月过的2级,总体感觉2次的难度都不高。3次都不高的概率因该很小吧...赫赫。这次我们要小心啦。 说到3级的教材,我的感觉和楼上不同。3级教材的实用性和可操作性我觉得最高,是3个级别的精华。一级是扫盲不提。2级是技术性的,电脑可代替的。3级才是融会贯通。但是说实用有个大大大的前提:立足在美国本土,做全球的投资和金融。这也是我今年来美后的体会,和以前在亚太区,完完全全不同的。这里法律和多样性都和别国很多不同。很多以前觉得的毫无意义的道德,文书什么的大水词,这里都是基本功。 考到3级才领悟到。CFA是美国自己关起门来的东西。赶在别的国家考的,总有凑热闹的嫌疑....
这个女人又跑这里来得瑟了。到美国几个月,脑子就烧瓦特了。

TOP

&nbsp;TNND,老子看英文就烦,你不会用中文呀?

TOP

2nd floor english is ok ba? can still understand ok.

TOP

觉得是bullshit,不考不就行了。。。又没人逼你考 真是搞笑

唧唧哇哇一大堆

TOP

无意义的争论就此打住了罢。刚从3级的紧张复习考试结束,手里的2个项目下周要开始,的确是要专心工作不可上班看论坛,呵呵。ls如果也是今年考了3级的,也都不是小孩子了,别让后来的学弟学妹看笑话吧。anyway, goodluck

TOP

11楼, 哪一个见到不同意见就杀气腾腾了?说你自己吧。你的意见站不住脚,就改人身攻击了。看你这口气,你是心胸宽广成了大器,怎么天天跑到这个论坛里挖坑灌水,寻找平衡呢?

TOP

楼上的请摆正心态。如果一个人用英文提问你用英文回答,中文的提问用中文回答是基本的礼貌,不用我教吧。楼上看到一不同意见就杀气腾腾的,非常激动啊。不谈“做人”先过“素质”关再与人说话吧。心胸狭隘,难成大器。祝你好运吧

TOP

返回列表