Why does it matter what we think? It really shouldn’t.
If you have an offer from both then you need to make the decision based on your own situation/objectives. Any questions you have would have hopefully been answered throughout the interview process.
If not then you aren’t really in a position to choose.
GS PWM adviser, because the ones I have seen or crossed path (professionally) doesn’t do anything..really! Well, they are well connected in town (rich peoplewise).