Janice Barefoot, CFA, has been managing a portfolio for a client who has asked Barefoot to use the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) as a benchmark. In her second year, Barefoot used 29 of the 30 DJIA stocks. She selected a non-DJIA stock in the same industry as the omitted DJIA stock to replace that stock. Compared to the DJIA, Barefoot placed a lower weight on the communication stocks and a higher weight on the other stocks still in the portfolio. Over that year, the non-DJIA stock in the portfolio had a positive and higher return than the omitted DJIA stock. The communication stocks had a negative return while all of the other stocks had a positive return. The portfolio managed by Barefoot outperformed the DJIA. Based on this we can say that the return from factor tilts and asset selection were:
A) |
negative and positive respectively. | |
|
C) |
positive and negative respectively. | |
Since the communications stocks had a negative return while all the other stocks had a positive return, Barefoot’s underweighting of those stocks produced a positive tilt return. Since the asset chosen to replace the DJIA stock outperformed the omitted stock, the asset selection return was positive. |