返回列表 发帖

Reading 26: Integration of Financial Statement Analysis Techn

Session 7: Financial Reporting and Analysis: Earnings Quality Issues
and Financial Ratio Analysis
Reading 26: Integration of Financial Statement Analysis Techniques

LOS e: Analyze and interpret the effects of balance sheet modifications, earnings normalization, and cash-flow-statement-related modifications on a company's financial statements, financial ratios, and overall financial condition.

 

 

 

Which of the following statements is correct when inventory prices are falling?

A)

LIFO results in lower COGS, higher earnings, higher taxes, and lower cash flows.

B)

LIFO results in higher COGS, lower earnings, higher taxes, and higher cash flows.

C)

LIFO results in lower COGS, lower earnings, lower taxes, and higher cash flows.




 

Remember, prices are falling.

Melinda McKay, CFA, an analyst at Integrity Equity, is considering an investment in Earthmovers Inc., whose most recent financial data is provided below.

Earthmovers Inc.

Income Statement

Year ended Dec 31, 2006

($U.S. thousands)

Revenues

20,152

Gross profit

10,022

Operating income

4,819

Depreciation

823

Interest expense

1,040

Income before taxes

2,956

Taxes

887

Net Income

2,069

Earthmovers Inc.

Balance Sheet

Year ended Dec 31, 2006

($U.S. thousands)

Assets

Liabilities & Owner’s Equity

Cash

600

Accounts payable

5,500

Marketable Securities

200

Notes payable

3,500

Accounts Receivable

8,500

Total current liabilities

9,000

Inventories

3,500

Total current assets

12,800

Long-term debt

13,000

Net P,P&E

17,000

Preferred stock (100,000 shares)

1,000

Pension Asset

1,500

Common Stock (500,000 shares)

2,000

Intangible Assets

1,000

Retained earnings

8,300

Goodwill

1,000

Total stockholder’s equity

11,300

Total Assets

33,300

Total liabilities & Equity

33,300

The footnotes to Earthmovers Inc. include the following information:

  • Inventories are valued at cost under the last in, first out (LIFO) method, the LIFO reserve is $1.2 million, up $120,000 from the previous year.

  • Capitalized interest for 2006 is $550,000.

  • Earthmovers recently sold $400,000 worth of accounts receivable with recourse. To date only $100,000 has been collected.

  • The funded status of the pension fund is a pension liability of $1,000,000.

  • Due to an increase in yields on corporate debt, the market value of the long-term debt is $12.35 million.

  • The preferred stock is redeemable at the option of the preferred stockholder.

  • The market value of the preferred stock is $9.50.

  • Management viewed the potential liability of $5 million associated with a pending lawsuit as an improbable event. There is no insurance in place to cover any potential loss.

Following the release of the financial statements, Earthmovers publicly acknowledged that the loss related to the lawsuit was a probable event and was working out a settlement for $3 million.

What is the value of the times interest earned ratio (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) / interest expense) using the adjusted data?

A)
3.0.
B)
2.8.
C)
4.6.



The income statement needs the following adjustments:


  • Capitalized interest should be included on the income statement.  Inclusion will not affect EBITDA but will increase interest expense to 1,590,000 (1,040,000 + 550,000).

  • EBITDA should be reduced by $300,000 ($400,000 ? $100,000) to $4,519,000 due to the sale of accounts receivable that are yet to be collected.

Therefore, EBITDA / interest expense is 2.8 (= 4,519,000 / 1,590,000).


What is the value of the current ratio using the adjusted data?

A)
1.54.
B)
1.45.
C)
1.41.



Current assets need the following adjustments:


  • Increase accounts receivable by $300,000 for the uncollected receivables sold with recourse.

  • Increase inventories by the amount of the LIFO reserve or $1.2 million to reflect first in, first out (FIFO) accounting.

Current liabilities should increase by $300,000 to reflect the “borrowing” related to the sale of the receivables.  

The adjusted current ratio is 1.54 [(12,800,000 + 300,000 + 1,200,000) / (9,000,000 + 300,000)]


What is the value of the leverage ratio (liabilities / equity) using the adjusted data?

A)
2.81.
B)
2.16.
C)
3.36.



The following balance sheet adjustments are indicated in the footnotes:

 

Adjustment

Long-term Assets

Long-term Liabilities

 

Equity

Pre-adjustment value

20,500,000

13,000,000

11,300,000

FIFO adjustment (1)

1,200,000

Capitalized interest (2)

(550,000)

(550,000)

Funded status of pension fund (3)

(1,500,000)

1,000,000

(2,500,000)

Market value of debt (4)

(650,000)

650,000

Redeemable preferred stock (5)

950,000

(950,000)

Lawsuit liability (6)

3,000,000

(3,000,000)

Goodwill (7)

(1,000,000)

(1,000,000)

Post-adjustment values

17,450,000

17,300,000

5,150,000

Notes:

(1) FIFO accounting gives the best estimate of the economic value of the inventory. Therefore, inventory and equity will increase by the LIFO reserve amount of $1.2 million.

(2) Capitalized interest should be removed from the balance sheet by reducing long-term assets and equity.

(3) The underfunded pension plan requires a compound adjustment. First, reduce assets and equity by the amount shown on the asset side of the balance sheet. Next, increase liabilities and decrease equity to reflect the amount of underfunding.

(4) The reduction in the value of the debt (650,000) is offset by an increase to equity.

(5) Because the preferred stock is redeemable it should be treated as a liability. Therefore, a liability of 950,000 (100,000 × 9.50) will reflect the market value of the preferred shares. The equity account is adjusted by 1) reducing equity by 1,000,000 to reflect the reclassification of the preferred stock to a liability and 2) increase equity by 50,000 to reflect the reduction in the value of the preferred shares (1,000,000 – 950,000). Therefore, the total adjustment is a reduction of 950,000.

(6) Because the settlement associated with the lawsuit is a probable event, that is measurable, it must be included in liabilities. The settlement amount of $3 million is used for the adjustment. A more aggressive stance would be to recognize the potential loss of $5 million if the analyst believed the settlement would not be accepted.

(7) Goodwill is eliminated and equity is reduced as an offset to the elimination.

The adjusted (liabilities / equity) ratio is 3.36 (= 17,300,000 / 5,150,000).

TOP

The Baker Company has an accrued postretirement benefit cost of $3 million on its balance sheet. Examining the notes to Baker's financial statements you find that the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation is $2.5 million. The adjustment you would make to Baker's reported balance sheet in analysis of these statements would be:

A)
an increase in plan assets of $0.5 million.
B)
an increase in the reported postretirement obligation of $0.5 million.
C)
a reduction in the reported postretirement obligation of $0.5 million.



The excess of the accrued cost over the obligation is the excess accrual (i.e., $3 million - 2.5 million), which reduces the firm's liability.

TOP

ABC Tie Company reports income for the year 2009 as $450,000. The notes to its financial statements state that the firm uses the last in, first out (LIFO) convention to value its inventories, and that had it used first in, first out (FIFO) instead, inventories would have been $62,000 greater for the year 2008 and $78,000 greater for the year 2009. If earnings were restated using FIFO to determine the cost of goods sold (COGS), what would the net income be for the year 2009? Assume a tax rate of 36%. Net income would have been:

A)

$455,760.

B)

$439,760.

C)

$460,240.




The reduction in COGS would result in an increase in net income (62,000 ? 78,000) × (1 ? 0.36).

TOP

Endrun Company reported net income of $4.7 million in 1999, and $4.3 million in 2000. In reviewing the annual report an analyst notices that the Endrun took a charge of $2.4 million in 1999 for the costs of relocating its main office, and in 2000 booked a gain of $900,000 on the sale of its previous office building. What would “normalized earnings” be for 1999 and 2000 if we assume a tax rate of 36% for both years?

A)

$7.1 million and $5.2 million.

B)

$6.236 million and $3.724 million.

C)

$3.99 million and $2.54 million.




You will increase 1999 earnings by the tax-adjusted value of the 2.4 million one-time charge (2.4 × (1 - 0.36) = +1.536), and you would decrease Y2000 earnings by the tax-adjusted amount of the $0.9 million one-time gain (0.9 × (1 - 0.36) = -0.576).

TOP

An investor relations spokesperson for the Square Door Corporation was quoted as saying that Square Door shares were a bargain, selling at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 12, relative to the S& 500 average P/E of 15.3. The financial statements reported net earnings of $126 million, or $4.00 per share. The notes to the financial statements included a statement that income for the year included a $31.5 million (after-tax) gain from the reclassification of certain assets from its investment portfolio to its trading portfolio. What would be the normalized P/E?

A)

15.

B)

13.

C)

16.




Since the P/E ratio was 12 and EPS was $4, the price of the stock was $48 (12 × 4).  After removing the nonrecurring gain, earnings will be $94.5 million (126 ? 31.5).  We know the number of shares is 31.5 million (126 Million ÷ 4).  So the new EPS number is 3 (94.5 million ÷ 31.5 million) and new P/E ratio is 16 (48 ÷ 3).


TOP

National Chemical Corp. (NCC) reports 2003 net earnings of $354.2 million. NCC’s financial statements and disclosures also indicate pretax impairment charges of $78.1 million and pretax amortization of $24.9 million. NCC also reports an after-tax loss of $23.4 million on the early retirement of debt and receipt of $118 million after-tax from an insurance claim. NCC effective tax rate is 36%. What are the normal operating earnings of NCC?

A)
$325.52 million.
B)
$414.68 million.
C)
$480.60 million.



NCC’s normal operating earnings are calculated as:

Net income

354.20

+ After-tax impairment charge

78.1 × (1 - 0.36) =

49.98

+ After-tax amortization charge

24.9 × (1 - 0.36) =

15.94

+ After-tax loss on debt retirement

23.40

? After-tax insurance settlement

118.00

Normal operating earnings

325.52

Recall that all adjustments are made on an after-tax basis.

TOP

A firm has reported net income of $136 million, but the notes to financial statements includes a statement that the results “include a $27 million charge for non-insured earthquake damage” and a “gain on the sale of certain assets during restructuring of $16 million.” If we assume that both of these items are given on a pre-tax basis and the effective tax rate is 36%, what would be the “normal operating income?”

A)

$94.08 million.

B)

$143.04 million.

C)

$147.00 million.




To normalize earnings you would increase it by the non-recurring charge of $27 million and decrease it by the non-recurring gain, both tax adjusted.

$136 + (27 - 16)(1 - 0.36) = $143.04.


TOP

An analyst finds return-on-equity (ROE) a good measure of management performance and wants to compare two firms: Firm A and Firm B. Firm A reports net income of $3.2 million and has a ROE of 18. Firm B reports income of $16 million and has an ROE of 16. A review of the notes to the financial statements for Firm A, shows that the earnings include a loss from smelting operations of $400,000 and that the firm has exited this business. In addition, the firm sold the smelting equipment and had a gain on the sale of $300,000. A similar review of the notes for Firm B discloses that the $16 million in net income includes $2.6 million gain on the sale of no longer needed office property. Assume that the tax rate for both firms is 36%, and that the notes describe pre-tax amounts. What would be the “normalized” ROE for Firm A and for Firm B, respectively?

A)

17.1 and 16.9.

B)

16.0 and 18.0.

C)

18.4 and 14.3.




The ROE for Firm A is adjusted for the $400,000 loss on discontinued operations and the $300,000 non-recurring gain. The ROE for Firm B is adjusted to remove the effects of the $2.6 million one-time gain.

TOP

MKF Consolidated reports $500 million in goodwill on its balance sheet. The market consensus indicates that the value of MKF’s intangible assets is $300 million. How should an analyst adjust MKF’s balance sheet? Reduce goodwill and:

A)
equity by $200 million.
B)
increase liabilities by $200 million.
C)
equity by $500 million.



If goodwill has no economic value apart from the firm, it should be eliminated from the balance sheet. If the value of the intangibles can be reliably estimated they can be substituted for accounting goodwill.

TOP

返回列表