Why is B wrong? - Financial Reporting and Analysis reported, following, understand, net

stockjaguar

Analysts should be wary of which of the following equity transactions a company may use to manipulate its reported earnings to reflect a higher net income? A company can move shares that have appreciated in value from:

A) available-for-sale to the trading portfolio.

B) held-to-maturity to the trading portfolio.

C) trading to the available-for-sale portfolio.


Your answer: B was incorrect. The correct answer was A) available-for-sale to the trading portfolio.
I understand why A is correct, and I was wondering about A or B, but went with B. Isn't that pretty much the same reason. The held to maturity would also increase in value and could be moved to trading portfolio to recognize the gains. Why is this wrong??? Anybody??

spreads

Makes sense. Thanks!

defour44

You're technically not allowed to move something from Held To Maturity to Trading, unless something REALLY legit comes up. If accounting govern bodies see your Corp doing this they will never allow you to classify anything for Held-to-Maturity again, and you will be the laughing stock of the neighborhood.

redskins44

Not to mention, the word "shares" indicates its an equity investment and equity investments can't be classified as HTM.

bdavi77962

@ Reggie Isn't that only under IFRS? Under US GAAP you can move the securities in and out of held for trading.