Arthur Hampton is reviewing the transcript of a lawmaking session during which a legislator made the following two statements:
Statement 1: The impact of a tax on the equilibrium price and quantity of a good or service will be the same whether the tax is legally imposed on the buyers or sellers.
Statement 2: The impact on the equilibrium price and quantity of a good or service of making trade in it illegal will be the same whether the penalty is imposed on the buyers or sellers.
With respect to these statements:
|
B) |
only statement 2 is correct. | |
C) |
only statement 1 is correct. | |
Hampton should agree with Statement 1 but disagree with Statement 2. In the trade of illegal goods, the effects of the prohibition depend on whether the penalties are imposed on the buyers or sellers. A penalty imposed on the buyers will shift the demand curve down by the value of the penalty buyers expect to bear. A penalty imposed on the sellers will shift the supply curve up by the value of the penalty sellers expect to bear. Other things equal, a penalty on buyers will result in a lower equilibrium price and a penalty on sellers will result in a higher equilibrium price. In either case the equilibrium quantity decreases. |