[CFA Level 2] 来研究下二级分数线吧 可能性, 先来

Libero

poor <=50%，不会太低，毕竟猜都有1/3机会了，取个整数估计：40%；
poor to average 51%-70%，取个中间值整数：60%；
above average >70%，中间值是85.5，但是满分和接近满分不多，就取整数80%。

毕竟有十个部分，所以都接近档位下限或都接近上限的可能性不大，多数此消彼长。

大家来爆一下计算出来的分数和Pass还是Fail，我先来：

3个poor，都是18分的；2个poor to average，一个18一个36；3个36和2个72的above average。

18*40%*3+18*60%+36*60%+36*80%*3+72*80*2=255.6

255.6/360=71% pass

conscript

给你两个极端例子，你来解释

Level 2: Pass

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 * - -

 - Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - * -

 - Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - * -

- Portfolio Management 18 * - -

- Quantitative Methods 18 - - *

 

Level 2: Fail

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 - - *

- Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - - *

- Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - - *

- Portfolio Management 18 - - *

- Quantitative Methods 18 * - -

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-8-20 12:00:18编辑过]

conscript

一个是论坛里的，一个来自analystforum，假设pass的每段得分49、69、99，fail的得分0、51、71，理论上讲还是pass的那位分高

Libero

 http://bbs.cfaspace.com/dispbbs.asp?boardid=24&Id=99181中几个代表性的Fail

70% Fail
73% Fail (著名的13楼)
69% Fail
67% Fail

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-8-20 12:19:32编辑过]

Libero

QUOTE:

以下是引用conscript在2009-8-20 11:59:00的发言：

给你两个极端例子，你来解释

Level 2: Pass

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 * - -

 - Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - * -

 - Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - * -

- Portfolio Management 18 * - -

- Quantitative Methods 18 - - *

 

Level 2: Fail

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 - - *

- Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - - *

- Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - - *

- Portfolio Management 18 - - *

- Quantitative Methods 18 * - -

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-8-20 12:00:18编辑过]

怎可能100正确？都接近上限/下限的可能性不大，不代表没有啊。但数据一多，不就能大约估出分数线吧，这对后来者应该有好处吧。

conscript

只是假设啦，具体得分只有协会知道

conscript

按你一楼的算法，我65%，我不但fail，还排到band7

Libero

QUOTE:

以下是引用conscript在2009-8-20 11:59:00的发言：

给你两个极端例子，你来解释

Level 2: Pass

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 * - -

 - Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - * -

 - Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - * -

- Portfolio Management 18 * - -

- Quantitative Methods 18 - - *

 

Level 2: Fail

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%

- Alternative Investments 18 - - *

- Corporate Finance 36 - - *

- Derivatives 36 - * -

- Economics 18 - - *

- Equity Investments 72 - - *

- Ethical & Professional Standards 36 - * -

- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - * -

- Fixed Income Investments 36 - - *

- Portfolio Management 18 - - *

- Quantitative Methods 18 * - -

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-8-20 12:00:18编辑过]

第一个好数据，62% Pass，理论最高分（9+36+24+18+48+24+48+24+9+18）/360=71.67%（分数线最大值）

第二个还好，70% Fail。

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-8-20 12:21:35编辑过]

conscript

Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%
- Alternative Investments 18 - - *
- Corporate Finance 36 - - *
- Derivatives 36 - * -
- Economics 18 * - -
- Equity Investments 72 - * -
- Ethical & Professional Standards 36 * - -
- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - - *
- Fixed Income Investments 36 - * -
- Portfolio Management 18 - - *
- Quantitative Methods 18 * - -

Band 9.

conscript

Item Set Q# Topic Max Pts <=50% 51%-70% >70%
- Alternative Investments 18 - * -
- Corporate Finance 36 - - *
- Derivatives 36 - - *
- Economics 18 - - *
- Equity Investments 72 - - *
- Ethical & Professional Standards 36 * - -
- Financial Reporting & Analysis 72 - - *
- Fixed Income Investments 36 * - -
- Portfolio Management 18 - * -
- Quantitative Methods 18 * - - 
band 9