标题: CFA got it wrong, or did I miss something? [打印本页] 作者: scr879 时间: 2013-4-3 19:37 标题: CFA got it wrong, or did I miss something?
Reading 56 (P152 question 4).
The question says “Over the longrun, you expect dividends for BBC in Problem 2 above to grow at 8% and u require 11% … .
In 2 the dividends was correctly calculated as (1) last year to be $6 and (2) this year to be $6.6, if the required rate has been changed to 11% why is the solution for D1$6*1.08/0.03 instead of $6.6*1.08/0.03.
My solution was $237,6. Did I miss something in the question or the solution.作者: chetan86 时间: 2013-4-3 19:41
PKJ, I agree with you. I believe it’s 6.6*1.08 on top, since you use the dividend for the period after the current one for the Gordon Growth Model.作者: smartpants 时间: 2013-4-3 19:44
cfagoal2 , I fully understand that required rate and g is not the same but your are not answering the question.
CFA used D0 instead of D1 and they had calculated D1 as $6.6 in the question 2 they are refering to in question 4, in my opinion their solution is wrong.
Thanks NYCAalyst86, I thought I was missing something作者: towardsutopia21 时间: 2013-4-3 19:46
Here is another one I think is wrong.
Sam’s Company expects to pay a dividend of $6 per share at the end of the year, $9 per share at the end of the next two years and then be sold for $136 per share. If the required rate on the stock is 20%, what is the current value of the stock
A) $100.1
B) 105.69
C) 110.00
Book answer is “B”
My answer is “None of the above”
Book solution is 6/1.2+9/1.2^2+136/1.2^2=105.69
My solution is 9/1.2+9/1.2^2+136/1.2^2=108.194作者: Flok 时间: 2013-4-3 19:48
Book is right
D1 = 6 see the END OF THE YEAR.
So you are at time 0 when they have not given you a dividend. At the end of the year means D1 = 6.
Does that now make sense in light of the answer?作者: manasib 时间: 2013-4-3 19:50
I just looked at the question in the book. The book is correct.
You ignore the back that it will earn $11 next year. You expect it to earn $10.8 next year, not $11.作者: hanvinh 时间: 2013-4-3 19:52
Shouldn’t it be 6/1.2+9/1.2^2+145/1.2^3? Did I misinterpret the question?作者: Maddin 时间: 2013-4-3 19:54
at the end of year 3 it is sold for 136. So though there is a 9$ dividend at the end of year 3 it is reflected in the P3 already.作者: cross-ied 时间: 2013-4-3 19:56
I think the question can be clearer. Most of the time when someone said the stock is sold for $x, we will assume $x is the market price i.e. excluding any dividends gained.
