| UID223230 帖子549 主题152 注册时间2011-7-11 最后登录2016-4-21 
 | 
| Using the following information from a firm that uses enterprise risk management, which portfolio manager has superior performance and why? | 
 | Manager A  | Manager B  |  | Capital
 | $150,000,000  | $590,000,000  |  | VAR
 | $7,500,000  | $21,000,000  |  | Profit
 | $2,000,000  | $7,000,000  | 
 | | A) 
 | Manager A because they had a higher return on capital. | 
 |  | | B) 
 | Manager A because they used less VAR. | 
 |  | | C) 
 | Manager B because their return is higher in a risk budgeting context. | 
 | 
 
 
 Using risk budgeting in enterprise risk management, we would divide the profit by the VAR allowed to generate a risk-adjusted performance measure. For manager A it is 26.7% (2,000,000 / 7,500,000). For Manager B it is 33.3% (7,000,000 / 21,000,000). Thus Manager B has better risk-adjusted performance. Note that the return on capital for each manager tells a different story. For manager A it is 1.3% (2,000,000 / 150,000,000) and it is 1.2% (7,000,000 / 590,000,000) for Manager B. So although the percentage return generated is higher for Manager A, we would conclude that Manager B has better performance when risk is considered.
 | 
 |